Even experts appeared perplexed ahead of the 2024 MLB Draft by the variety of potential paths the Yankees could take with the 26th overall pick.
This selection, of course, constituted a ten-spot decrease from where New York should have been; their initial pick slipped ten spaces due to how far they surpassed the luxury tax.
With that in mind, and with plenty of collegiate bats meeting the Yankees’ profile still available, Brian Cashman and his staff chose Alabama’s Ben Hess as a “big, physical” starting pitcher. Hess, MLB Pipeline’s 44th-ranked prospect, has the greatest K-per-9 rate in Crimson Tide history.
He’s also entering the draft broadcast far sooner than expected.
Yankees Select Alabama Pitcher Ben Hess with 26th Overall Pick
The Yankees’ choice to select Alabama right-handed pitcher Ben Hess with the 26th overall pick in the MLB Draft surprised many, especially the analysts on MLB Network’s draft broadcast. They noted that Hess doesn’t fit the typical profile of pitchers the Yankees usually select. While scouts confirmed that Hess has the potential to be a major-league pitcher, concerns about his medical history were expected to push him out of the first round. This raises the question of whether the Yankees were aware of these medical issues.
From a traditional statistics standpoint, Hess finished the 2024 season with a 5.80 ERA, although he did record 106 strikeouts, which offers a glimpse of his potential despite the discouraging ERA.
Questioning the Yankees’ Decision
The Yankees have a solid track record in developing collegiate pitchers, and Hess’s personality seems to be a good fit for the organization. However, it’s fair to question the decision to select him in the first round. The analysts suggested that the Yankees’ strategy to “unlock” Hess would typically be something they would attempt with a second or third-round pick.
With high-profile players like LSU’s Tommy White and Kentucky’s Ryan Waldschmidt still available, it seems reasonable to question if the Yankees saw something in Hess that others missed or if they overestimated their ability to develop him. The analysts speculated whether the Yankees might have outsmarted themselves with this pick and wondered who else was in the running for Hess.
Potential and Risk
Hess has undeniable talent, as indicated by his high strikeout numbers, but his elevated ERA and the reported medical concerns make this pick a high-risk, high-reward scenario. The Yankees’ confidence in their development system will be put to the test as they work to refine Hess’s skills and manage any health issues.
In conclusion, while the selection of Ben Hess by the Yankees at 26th overall has raised eyebrows and prompted questions, the ultimate success of this pick will depend on how effectively the Yankees can develop his potential and navigate any underlying health concerns.
