The New York Yankees are entering a pivotal offseason with a clear focus on improving their roster. While keeping Juan Soto is central to their plans, the team is also exploring other avenues to strengthen the infield. One name gaining attention is Alex Bregman, the 30-year-old star infielder, who could be a strong fit for the Yankees, as reports suggest the team is interested in acquiring him.
Bregman, a two-time All-Star, Gold Glove winner, and World Series champion, offers a unique mix of offensive power and defensive prowess. Should the Yankees pursue him, Bregman could fill either third base or second base, depending on the final composition of their infield.
Bregman’s Versatility and Consistent Offense
While Bregman has primarily played third base throughout his career, he has also shown the ability to play second base—something he recently indicated he would be open to. In 2024, he logged 1,234.2 innings at third base, showcasing elite defensive skills with a .972 fielding percentage, six defensive runs saved, and six outs above average. His willingness to shift to second base gives the Yankees flexibility, allowing them to move Jazz Chisholm back to his natural position at second.
At the plate, Bregman has been one of the most reliable hitters in baseball. In 2024, he posted a .260/.315/.453 slash line, with 26 home runs, 75 RBIs, and a 118 wRC+. His ability to consistently produce strong offensive numbers makes him an appealing option for the Yankees, who struggled with lineup consistency last season.
Bregman’s exceptional plate discipline stands out as well. He ranks in the 98th percentile for whiff rate and 82nd for chase rate, which means he rarely swings at bad pitches—an attribute that would complement the Yankees’ preference for on-base percentage and patient at-bats.
However, Bregman’s power may not fully translate to Yankee Stadium. In 2023, Bregman hit 29 homers, but if playing in the Bronx, he would have only hit 21 due to the deeper left-field dimensions. This could be a factor in evaluating his potential production at home.
Addressing Defensive Needs
One of the Yankees’ main weaknesses in 2024 was defense, which was exposed in the World Series against the Dodgers. Adding Bregman would immediately improve the infield defense, whether he plays third or second base. At third, he would replace Chisholm, who has performed well defensively but prefers to play second base. This move would maximize both players’ defensive strengths. If Bregman shifts to second, he would upgrade the position over any internal options, including Caleb Durbin, who is talented but untested at the MLB level.
Bregman’s ability to make crucial plays and his leadership would address some of the defensive lapses the Yankees faced last season, bringing stability to high-pressure situations.
Leadership and Postseason Experience
Another reason the Yankees might target Bregman is his extensive playoff experience. With 99 postseason games under his belt, Bregman has the proven ability to perform in October, which would be invaluable for a team aiming to bounce back after falling short in the 2024 World Series.
His leadership qualities would also complement the established presence of Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole, further strengthening the Yankees’ clubhouse culture and focus on returning to championship contention.
Financial Considerations and Potential Contract
Bregman is coming off a five-year, $100 million contract and is expected to command a substantial deal this offseason. Projections suggest he could sign a seven-year contract worth around $185.5 million, averaging $26.4 million annually. Although this is a significant investment, the Yankees have the financial flexibility to make such a move, particularly if they find creative ways to defer money or offload other contracts, like Marcus Stroman’s $18.5 million salary.
While a seven-year contract comes with risks, Bregman’s consistent production and defensive value make him a safer bet compared to many other free agents. Additionally, his ability to play multiple positions would provide the Yankees with much-needed roster flexibility throughout the long season.
A Perfect Fit for the Yankees’ Lineup
Should the Yankees land Bregman, he would complement a lineup that could include Juan Soto, Aaron Judge, and Gleyber Torres (if retained). Bregman’s power, ability to get on base, and knack for working deep counts would align well with the Yankees’ offensive approach. He could bat second, ahead of Judge and Soto, or contribute further down the order, depending on the team’s needs.
Conclusion
Alex Bregman is an ideal target for the Yankees this offseason, offering top-tier defense, consistent offense, and invaluable postseason experience. Whether at third base or second, Bregman would address several weaknesses and significantly boost the Yankees’ chances of returning to the World Series in 2025.
While retaining Juan Soto remains the priority, adding a player of Bregman’s caliber could prove to be the key for the Yankees, especially as rivals like the Mets and Dodgers aggressively strengthen their rosters. The Yankees must act decisively to bring in players who can help them contend for championships in both the short and long term.
