The New York Yankees created an opening at first base by declining Anthony Rizzo’s $17 million club option for 2025. As speculation swirls about how they’ll address the position—especially given their pursuit of Cody Bellinger and a third baseman this offseason—they may need to manage payroll carefully. While free agent Christian Walker remains an obvious choice, the Yankees could consider a more cost-effective and creative solution.
Enter Josh Naylor, the Cleveland Guardians’ first baseman, who has been rumored to be on the trade block this winter. A potential trade that would bring Naylor to New York could look like this:
New York Yankees receive: 1B Josh Naylor
Cleveland Guardians receive: RHP Cade Smith (No. 13 prospect) and INF Jorbit Vivas (No. 17 prospect)
Naylor has consistently performed at a high level, posting an OPS+ of 118 or better in each of the past three seasons. He’s projected to make about $14 million through arbitration in 2025—cheaper than Rizzo’s buyout or signing Walker.
For Cleveland, trading Naylor would allow them to add two promising prospects to their farm system while moving on from an expiring contract. Smith, 22, is a right-hander with strong stuff and a high ceiling, while Vivas has an extensive minor league background, though his 2024 performance was less impressive.
Naylor has a complicated history with Yankees ace Gerrit Cole, that shouldn’t be a roadblock. While their past interactions might raise eyebrows, the business side of baseball takes precedence, especially with veterans like Aaron Judge in the clubhouse fostering a positive environment. Naylor and Cole would likely be able to put their differences aside without issue.
This trade would be a smart, affordable move for the Yankees, addressing their need at first base while maintaining financial flexibility as they target other high-profile acquisitions this winter.
