The New York Yankees have been linked to potential trade talks involving a high-profile third baseman, but the chances of this trade happening seem slim. While reports initially suggested the Yankees might engage more seriously with the St. Louis Cardinals after Alex Bregman signed with the Red Sox, trusted sources, including well-known reporters from New York, have denied any real intention to pursue this player.
At this point, the Yankees are in need of an infielder as Opening Day approaches, but making a move for an established player could complicate their future plans. Despite the team’s need for an upgrade at third base, this trade would likely hurt their financial flexibility down the line. With the team already committed to a significant contract with DJ LeMahieu, adding another pricey contract could prevent the Yankees from making future moves to improve their roster.
The player in question is Nolan Arenado. While Arenado is undeniably one of the league’s top defenders and has a solid offensive record, his declining offensive numbers in recent years make him a risky acquisition. His $17.3 million annual salary over the next three years would be a hefty price for the Yankees, particularly considering his swing may not be well-suited to Yankee Stadium.
Moreover, even though Arenado would undoubtedly improve the Yankees’ defense at third base, his bat has shown signs of regression. In addition, with the potential for him to underperform, it could lead to a situation where the Yankees are stuck with a declining player on a large contract. If Arenado were to struggle, would the Yankees still be willing to bench him or trade him midseason? The team’s reluctance to commit long-term to infield upgrades makes this a tough decision.
While the Yankees could potentially add value by also acquiring a key reliever like Ryan Helsley from the Cardinals, such a trade would involve further financial strain. Helsley, one of the top relievers in baseball, is owed money as well, which adds another layer of complexity.
In conclusion, the trade for Nolan Arenado seems unlikely due to the Yankees’ current roster construction and financial constraints. While Arenado could bring value, his high salary, declining offensive numbers, and potential fit issues with the team make this trade a risky move for the Yankees.
