The New York Yankees made several significant moves this offseason, from acquiring key players like Max Fried, Cody Bellinger, and Devin Williams, to shaking up their long-standing facial hair policy. But despite their efforts to improve, there’s one offseason loss that continues to sting: the departure of a top-tier free agent to a bitter rival.
The Yankees, traditionally known for their strict rules and policies, have always operated with a sense of tradition—some of it more outdated than others. One of the most discussed changes this offseason was the removal of the Yankees’ facial hair rule, which for years prohibited players from growing beards. Now, players are free to maintain well-groomed facial hair, signaling a shift in the organization’s approach.
But as progressive as that policy change might seem, the Yankees may have missed the mark in other areas that contributed to a more painful loss. In fact, the Yankees lost a high-profile free agent to the Mets, and the reasons for his decision weren’t just about money.
While many were quick to point to the financial power of Mets owner Steve Cohen, who offered a staggering $765 million contract for the next 15 years, there were other factors at play—ones that reveal cracks in the Yankees’ traditional practices.
One of the more surprising issues was the Yankees’ refusal to provide a suite for the player’s family and friends last season. A simple gesture like this could have made all the difference, but the Yankees stood by their precedent, much to the dismay of the player in question.
The refusal wasn’t the main reason for his departure, but it certainly didn’t help matters. It wasn’t just the player’s personal feelings at stake; even past Yankees legends like Aaron Judge and Derek Jeter have struggled with this same policy.
So who was this high-profile free agent who ultimately chose the Mets over the Yankees, despite all the potential for success in the Bronx? None other than Juan Soto, the star outfielder who was one of the most sought-after players this offseason.
While Soto was always expected to command a massive deal, the Yankees’ rigid policies may have played a role in pushing him away. Soto’s decision to sign with the Mets isn’t just a reflection of their financial offer, but also how the Yankees’ refusal to adapt in certain areas might have cost them.
