In a decision that has left New York Giants fans furious, the team used their No. 3 overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft in a way that many fans didn’t expect. With plenty of pressing needs to address, the Giants’ first-round selection raised eyebrows and caused a stir among the fanbase. The pick was met with a wave of criticism, as fans were left questioning the team’s priorities moving forward.
The Giants entered the draft with high expectations, as they needed to address the quarterback position and bolster other key areas of the roster. Many thought the team would take a quarterback with their top pick, a move that seemed almost inevitable given their struggles at the position in recent years. But when the announcement came, it wasn’t a quarterback that the Giants selected—it was a position that many felt could have waited.
The Giants shocked fans by choosing Ashton Jeanty, a running back from Boise State, with their first-round pick. While Jeanty’s 2024 season was nothing short of extraordinary, with historic numbers and Heisman Trophy consideration, many fans were frustrated. The Giants have a promising young back in Tyrone Tracy Jr., and with other glaring needs, especially at quarterback, the choice to draft a running back at such a high spot felt like a misstep.
This decision has sparked outrage on social media, with fans voicing their anger and disappointment. The frustration is compounded by the fact that the Giants let Saquon Barkley walk away to a division rival, and now they’ve used their precious first-round pick on another running back. To many, it feels like an overcorrection, especially with the team needing so much help elsewhere.
Jeanty’s talent is undeniable, but fans are struggling to see how this move will help the Giants’ long-term success. As the franchise looks to build a competitive roster, the decision to prioritize a running back—when so many other positions require immediate attention—has led to serious doubts about the direction the team is heading. Whether this pick turns out to be a game-changer or a mistake, one thing is clear: Giants fans are not happy with this shocking first-round selection.
