As the 2025 season approaches, the New York Giants have been actively searching for a new quarterback. They reportedly made a strong push for Matthew Stafford, but he quickly re-signed with the Los Angeles Rams for at least another season.
The Giants are also eyeing Aaron Rodgers, who has been considering multiple teams recently. However, whether or not Rodgers joins the Giants, the team needs to explore the 2025 NFL Draft class to ensure they’re covered at quarterback.
An unexpected candidate has recently emerged as a top option for the Giants, and it’s someone they could end up “falling in love with.”
An Unexpected Quarterback Option for the Giants
In a March 19 piece for Big Blue View, NFL analyst Chris Pflum highlighted that the Giants are likely to draft a quarterback in the 2025 NFL Draft. With their former franchise quarterback, Daniel Jones, now with the Colts, the Giants’ biggest need is at the quarterback position. Even if they sign a veteran like Rodgers, it’s wise to also bring in a young player to develop.
While the Giants have been scouting the top quarterback prospects for this draft, including familiar names like Shedeur Sanders from Colorado and Cameron Ward from the University of Miami, an under-the-radar candidate has risen in importance—Alabama’s Jalen Milroe.
Pflum points out that Milroe possesses several traits that could make him a great fit for the Giants: intelligence, hard work, accountability, elite athleticism, and a strong arm. He’s also considered the quarterback with the most untapped potential.
“Milroe has the highest ceiling and lowest floor of any top quarterback prospect,” Pflum says. “This duality might scare teams who are risk-averse, but it could also intrigue those willing to take a chance on his upside.”
Concerns About Milroe
While Milroe has showcased his physical abilities and athleticism, there are concerns about his readiness. He’s still developing and may not be able to step in immediately like other top prospects, such as Caleb Williams. For example, Milroe’s performance in Alabama’s game against Michigan was underwhelming—he completed 16 of 32 passes for 192 yards, 1 touchdown, 1 interception, and only 7 rushing yards.
Despite these questions, sometimes taking a risk can pay off. Don’t be surprised if Milroe ends up making his home in New York.
