For many years, the ideal leadoff hitter was seen as a fast player who could get on base, steal second, move to third on an out, and score. However, it took a while for teams to realize that many speedy players often lacked consistency at the plate. A leadoff man who couldn’t get on base was not as effective as originally thought.
Today, speedsters with low on-base percentages have largely been moved to the ninth spot, with more patient hitters who also possess power taking the leadoff role. A solid hitter who can get on base or hit for extra bases sets up opportunities for more runs and big innings, including the occasional leadoff home run.
While speed/power combinations are still ideal, the preference now is for a hitter with a good eye who can start the game strong. Kyle Schwarber is a prime example of this evolution. His role as a powerful leadoff hitter for the Phillies has made him a trendsetter, and his success may soon inspire other teams, including the Yankees, to rethink their approach to the top of the lineup.
Last season, the Yankees saw their offense improve when Gleyber Torres was moved to the top of the order. His on-base percentage soared, particularly in August and September, and he hit five home runs. His hot stretch helped him salvage an otherwise tough season and finish above average.
This offseason, the Yankees allowed Torres to leave for Detroit, but his valuable leadoff presence departed with him. Against expectations, New York may have found a similarly unconventional solution in Austin Wells, who’s ready to step up as a leadoff hitter despite not being the traditional choice.
Wells’ emergence as a leadoff option is surprising, especially when compared to how outlandish the idea would have seemed five to ten years ago. While the Yankees would love Anthony Volpe to take the leadoff role eventually, for now, he needs more development. Wells, who lacks top-tier speed, has shown impressive power and patience this spring, hitting three home runs with a 1.209 OPS in just 22 at-bats.
Though Torres was not a major loss for defense or the New York spotlight, he regained his confidence in the second half of the season, reminding everyone of his playoff potential. If Wells takes over the leadoff role, he’ll need to maintain that same swagger to fill Torres’ shoes. Spring training numbers aren’t the final word, but Wells’ impressive start has certainly shown he’s ready to make an impact.
One thing remains clear: Torres won’t forget the Yankees. His comments this spring have shown that the team will always have a place in his heart, even though he’s now with Detroit.
