Hello MLB and New York Yankees fans! Welcome to the latest edition of Mistretta’s Musings. Before Yankees fans get upset at the idea of anyone challenging Aaron Judge for the 2025 American League MVP, it’s important to note that having a Yankees player in MVP contention is a good sign for the team.
And for MLB fans who think I’m overreacting to a strong start, let’s break down why Cody Bellinger could have a standout 2025 season in New York.
While Judge is the 2024 American League MVP and will likely be in the MVP conversation again in 2025, this discussion isn’t about questioning his chances. Instead, it’s about how Bellinger could be the perfect addition to the Yankees lineup.
Many fans may be asking, “What about Bobby Witt Jr.?” He’s definitely a contender, and he was a popular pick for AL MVP before the season. The Kansas City Royals shortstop is becoming one of the best players in baseball.
But how can Bellinger enter the MVP race alongside Judge and Witt?
Bellinger’s potential for an MVP run isn’t just based on his hot start against the Milwaukee Brewers, where he posted a .400/.357/.700/1.057 slash line in three games. He’s likely to hit second in the lineup ahead of Judge, which will give him ample opportunities to see good pitches.
Pitchers won’t want to risk walking him with Judge waiting behind him, providing Bellinger with some of the best pitches of his career.
A former MVP (2019), Bellinger also brings speed and defense—two areas where the Yankees have struggled in recent years. While he’s not expected to lead the league in stolen bases, he has stolen 14 or more bases in four different seasons. The Yankees may even encourage him to steal more to get into scoring position regularly.
Additionally, Bellinger can play any outfield spot and first base if needed. If he continues in left field, he could earn Gold Glove consideration, having won the award in 2019.
