The New York Giants hold the third overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, and much of the buzz has centered on which quarterback they might choose. But there’s an alternative route that could pay off more in the long run—even if it’s not what fans are expecting.
Instead of forcing a quarterback selection they’re unsure about, the Giants could opt to take the best overall talent at No. 3 and still snag a potential game-changing quarterback in the second round.
That quarterback? Alabama’s Jalen Milroe.
A Rare Talent Hiding in Plain Sight
Milroe might not fit the mold of a polished, NFL-ready passer, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. What he lacks in consistency on short and intermediate throws, he makes up for with a unique, game-breaking skill: elite rushing ability.
In 2024, Milroe ran for 879 yards and scored 20 touchdowns on the ground—yes, really. Averaging almost six yards per carry, he’s nearly impossible to tackle in open space. Built like a linebacker, he moves like a running back and attacks like a runaway train.
“He’s the best running quarterback I’ve ever evaluated. Think Cam Newton’s power with Lamar Jackson’s speed,” an AFC coordinator told NFL insider Tom Pelissero.
Deep Passing? Already a Strength
Although Milroe’s accuracy on shorter throws still needs refinement, he already excels with the deep ball. On passes over 20 yards last season, he totaled 892 yards, 10 touchdowns, and just three interceptions, completing nearly 40% of those high-risk throws. That shows he’s got the arm and field vision to stretch defenses vertically.
His decision-making and short-range passing still need work, but that’s something time and coaching can fix.
A Perfect Development Project
With veteran Russell Wilson on the roster for 2025, the Giants could let Milroe sit and develop. Under head coach Brian Daboll—known for unlocking the potential of quarterbacks with unique skill sets—Milroe could take a year to refine his game and adjust to NFL speed.
Come 2026, he might be ready to take over, bringing a dual-threat presence that could completely change how defenses prepare for New York.
A Smarter Strategy at No. 3?
Instead of reaching for a quarterback like Shedeur Sanders who may carry some uncertainty, the Giants could select a defensive star like Abdul Carter with their top pick. Then, they could target Milroe in the second round—adding a dynamic defender and a high-upside quarterback without sacrificing top-tier draft value.
In a league constantly hunting for the next unique quarterback talent, Milroe may not be the polished product today—but with the right setup, he could become something truly special.
All the Giants need is foresight—and patience.
