In a surprising move that has caught many by surprise, the Kansas City Royals have decided to part ways with one of their most promising young outfielders. This decision comes after several seasons in which the outfielder showed glimpses of immense potential but struggled to find the consistency necessary to make a major impact at the big league level. Despite flashes of brilliance, including a strong 2024 season, the player’s inconsistency at the plate ultimately led to the Royals deciding it was time for a change.
After three years with the Royals, MJ Melendez has found a new home with the New York Giants. Known for his raw power and athleticism, Melendez was often viewed as one of the Royals’ most exciting prospects. However, his journey in Kansas City was filled with both highs and lows, and his inability to develop a consistent approach at the plate became a growing concern. While he showed promise with 17 home runs in 2024, his swing-and-miss tendencies and lack of plate discipline ultimately held him back from realizing his true potential.
“I had some good stretches, but I never felt like I showed who I really am as a player,” Melendez said about his time with Kansas City. “I knew I had more to give, and I just didn’t feel like I was able to consistently do that here.”
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/72245533/usa_today_20357069.0.jpg)
The decision to part ways with Melendez was not an easy one for the Royals. The team had long believed in his potential, but with a rebuilding effort in full swing, they felt it was time for both Melendez and the franchise to move in new directions. “We’ve always known the talent MJ has, and we’ve seen flashes of brilliance from him,” Royals GM J.J. Picollo shared. “But ultimately, we felt it was the right time for him to find a new opportunity, and for us to continue building for the future.”
Now in New York, Melendez will have the chance to reset and develop further. The Giants see the outfielder as a player who can still tap into his immense physical tools, with the potential to become a key contributor to their offense. With a few adjustments to his swing and approach, the Giants believe Melendez can realize his potential at the plate.
“MJ has the physical tools to be an impactful player,” said Giants manager Gabe Kapler. “With a few tweaks to his approach, we think he can really take off. We’re excited to bring him on board and see how he can help us in 2025.”
For Melendez, this move is an opportunity to prove himself once again. New York offers a fresh start and a chance to develop the consistency that has eluded him in Kansas City. As he embarks on this new journey, all eyes will be on Melendez as he seeks to unlock his full potential with the Giants. Meanwhile, the Royals will continue their rebuilding process, focusing on the future and developing young talent as they move forward.
